Song 8 of 20
Song 8 of 20
Embedded Files
Many years have passed, and the couple's children are now grown. The narrator sits with his adult son and looks through old family photographs. Each picture brings back a different period: young children, old furniture, household repairs, family gatherings and evenings that once seemed unimportant. Father and son begin moving through decades together, recognizing people and places that belonged to earlier versions of their family life.
You set that box down by my chairI poured two cups and pulled them nearYour mother smiled; I bent the factsWe laughed our way through all the stacksThat plaid couch ran us twenty-fiveThe Ford played dead but stayed aliveYour red bike waited by the wallYou looked too small to ride at allYour cheek lay warm and still against my sleeveMy younger hands held more than I believed
Where did those years go? I still want to knowDay after day, we never saw them goOld bills, boots, and bedtimes still crowd the hallYears now lie flat in a box by the wall
We worked long shifts and counted changeMade supper on a borrowed rangeI fought that toy till two o’clockYour mother fixed it with one knockThe furnace failed that winter nightWe wore our coats till morning lightI snapped at you when work ran lateThen read you stories after eight
We made each dollar carry twice its shareWe built our life from thrift-store folding chairs
Where did those years go? I still want to knowDay after day, we never saw them goOld bills, boots, and bedtimes still crowd the hallYears now lie flat in a box by the wall
I found a print from New Year's EveYou slept against my flannel sleeveYour head was tucked beneath my chinI felt each breath against my skinI looked from then to you todayThe years had changed, not gone awayYour boy laughs just the way you didI found the father in my kid
I watched you hold him to your chestHis small hand curled, his cheek at restI knew what we were holding thenThe boy, the man, the boy again
Where did those years go? They never went farThey’re in your boy and the man that you areI see all those years here sitting with meThose years made the father you came to be
I closed the box; the afternoon turned goldYou left with more than pictures you could hold
Where did those years go? I still want to knowDay after day, we never saw them goOld bills, boots, and bedtimes still crowd the hallYears now lie flat in a box by the wall
We worked long shifts and counted changeMade supper on a borrowed rangeI fought that toy till two o’clockYour mother fixed it with one knockThe furnace failed that winter nightWe wore our coats till morning lightI snapped at you when work ran lateThen read you stories after eight
We made each dollar carry twice its shareWe built our life from thrift-store folding chairs
Where did those years go? I still want to knowDay after day, we never saw them goOld bills, boots, and bedtimes still crowd the hallYears now lie flat in a box by the wall
I found a print from New Year's EveYou slept against my flannel sleeveYour head was tucked beneath my chinI felt each breath against my skinI looked from then to you todayThe years had changed, not gone awayYour boy laughs just the way you didI found the father in my kid
I watched you hold him to your chestHis small hand curled, his cheek at restI knew what we were holding thenThe boy, the man, the boy again
Where did those years go? They never went farThey’re in your boy and the man that you areI see all those years here sitting with meThose years made the father you came to be
I closed the box; the afternoon turned goldYou left with more than pictures you could hold
Behind The Song
Behind The Song
What We Were Holding begins with one of adulthood's strangest questions:
Where did all those years go?
The first answer is usually unsatisfying: they passed.
But the father looking through the photographs begins to see something more concrete.
The years became things.
They became a grown son. Skills. Family stories. Habits. Mistakes corrected. Problems solved. A child who became a father himself. A grandson laughing with an echo of the boy who came before him.
Time did not sit in a container waiting to be preserved. It was converted into a life.
That does not make the father's longing foolish. He can miss the small boy who once slept against his chest. That configuration of reality is gone.
But the adult son sitting across from him is not evidence that the earlier years disappeared meaninglessly.
He is evidence that they happened.
This is an important expansion of the album's argument about impermanence. Something can end as a form while continuing through consequences.
Parenthood makes this especially visible. Raising a child correctly requires participating in the destruction of the very arrangement one may later miss. The helpless infant is supposed to become capable. The small hand is supposed to grow. The child is supposed eventually to possess a life not organized around the parent.
Success creates the loss.
And yet the loss is not failure.
The father's younger hands could not fully understand what they were holding because some values become visible only across time.
Now he sees it.
The years are not hiding in the photographs.
They are sitting across the table from him.
The Takeaway
The Takeaway
The years do not simply disappear. They are spent into people, skills, character, relationships, consequences and the person we eventually become. We can ask where the years went while sitting across from one of their answers, and realize that time was not merely lost because it cannot be recovered. It was used to make a life.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse